The past and future of the AHP in health care decision making

Objective. Health care decision making is a complex process involving many stakeholders and allowing for multiple decision criteria. The Analytic Hierarchy process (AHP) can support these complex decisions that relate to the application and coverage of health care technologies. The objective of this study is to review the past applications of the AHP in supporting health care decision making, and to make recommendations for its future use.\ud Method. We conducted a systematic review of AHP applications in health care, as described in the relevant medical, health-economical, psycho-sociological, managerial, and applied mathematical literature.\ud Results. We found 62 distinctive AHP applications in health care. Of the retrieved applications, 13 % focus on shared decision-making between patient and clinician, 27 % on the development of clinical practice guidelines, 5 % on the development of medical devices and pharmaceuticals, 40 % on management decisions in health care organizations, and 15 % on the development of national health care policy.\ud Conclusions. From the review it is concluded that the AHP is suitable to apply in case of complex health care decision problems, a need to improve decision making in stead of explain decision outcomes, a need to share information among experts or between clinicians and patients, and in case of a limited availability of informed respondents. We foresee the increased use of the AHP in health economical assessment of technology

Feasibility of the physiological cost index as an outcome measure for the assessment of energy expenditure during walking

Objective: To determine if the Physiological Cost Index (PCI) can be recommended as an outcome measure in clinical trials. Design: Three assessments were performed, 2 with shoes, 1 without. The difference between walking with shoes and walking barefoot was used to study the ability of the PCI to detect a change in the criterion standard. Setting: A research department affiliated with a rehabilitation hospital in the Netherlands. Participants: Twelve children with cerebral palsy. Interventions: During the first and third assessments, the children walked with shoes. During the intermediate assessment, the children walked without shoes. Main Outcome Measures: Breath-by-breath oxygen uptake, heart rate (HR), and walking speed were measured at a self-selected comfortable speed. Oxygen cost (EO2) and the PCI were subsequently calculated offline. Feasibility judgments were made regarding the ability of the PCI to detect changes in a criterion standard and the statistical power of the outcome measure. Results: Pearson correlation coefficients were .66 and .62 for HRwalking-HRbaseline and HRwalking, respectively. The smallest detectable difference of the PCI and EO2 were 69% and 32%, respectively. A difference of at least 69% or 32% should be found before one can conclude a difference with a certainty of 95%. Conclusions: The reproducibility of the PCI and the ability to show small differences in EO2 were moderate. Subtracting HRbaseline when calculating the PCI is probably not useful because it only increased within-subject variability. With respect to statistical power of a new clinical trial, we recommend using EO2 instead of the PCI

Analysis of healthy sitting behavior: Interface pressure distribution and subcutaneous tissue oxygenation

Pressure ulcers are a large problem in individuals who use a wheelchair for their mobility and have limited trunk stability and motor function. Because no relation between interface pressure and pressure ulcer development has been established and no clinical threshold for pressure ulcer development can be given, looking at the sitting behavior of nondisabled individuals is important. Nondisabled individuals do not develop pressure ulcers because they continuously shift posture. We analyzed the sitting behavior of 25 nondisabled male subjects by using a combination of interface pressure measurement and subcutaneous tissue oxygenation measurement by means of the Oxygen to See. These subjects shifted posture on average 7.8 +/- 5.2 times an hour. These posture shifts were merely a combination of posture shifts in the frontal and sagittal plane. Subcutaneous oxygen saturation increased on average 2.2% with each posture adjustment, indicating a positive effect of posture shifts on tissue viability. The results of this study can be used as a reference for seating interventions aimed at preventing pressure ulcers. Changing the sitting load at least every 8 minutes is recommended for wheelchair users

Assessment of the added value of the Twente Photoacoustic Mammoscope in breast cancer diagnosis\ud

Purpose: Photoacoustic (PA) imaging is a recently developed breast cancer imaging technique. In order to enhance successful clinical implementation, we quantified the potential clinical value of different scenarios incorporating PA imaging by means of multi-criteria analysis. From this analysis, the most promising area of application for PA imaging in breast cancer diagnosis is determined, and recommendations are provided to optimize the design of PA imaging. - \ud Methods: The added value of PA imaging was assessed in two areas of application in the diagnostic track. These areas include PA imaging as an alternative to x-ray mammography and ultrasonography in early stage diagnosis, and PA imaging as an alternative to Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) in later stage diagnosis. The added value of PA imaging was assessed with respect to four main criteria (costs, diagnostic performance, patient comfort and risks). An expert panel composed of medical, technical and management experts was asked to assess the relative importance of the criteria in comparing the alternative diagnostic devices. The judgments of the experts were quantified based on the validated pairwise comparison technique of the Analytic Hierarchy Process, a technique for multi-criteria analysis. Sensitivity analysis was applied to account for the uncertainty of the outcomes. - \ud Results: Among the considered alternatives, PA imaging is the preferred technique due to its non-invasiveness, low cost and low risks. However, the experts do not expect large differences in diagnostic performance. The outcomes suggest that design changes to improve the diagnostic performance of PA imaging should focus on the quality of the reconstruction algorithm, detector sensitivity, detector bandwidth and the number of wavelengths used. - \ud Conclusion: The AHP method was useful in recommending the most promising area of application in the diagnostic track for which PA imaging can be implemented, this being early diagnosis, as a substitute for the combined use of x-ray mammography and ultrasonography

Netwerk in beweging... door technologische innovaties in de neurorevalidatie

Er zijn vele neurologische aandoeningen bekend, maar ik zal me vandaag beperken tot een tweetal voor de revalidatie belangrijke, de hersenbloeding (of herseninfarct) en de dwarslaesie. Dit zijn beide centraal neurologische aan- doeningen, hetgeen betekent dat het aandoeningen zijn van het centrale zenuwstelsel (de hersenen of ruggenmerg)